1913 arrest of Joe Masseria for burglary. Masseria and Lagattuta were convicted of burglary. Sentencing occurred on May 23. Lagattuta was sentenced to serve between two and a half and five years in prison. Because Masseria had a previous criminal record, he was sentenced to four to six years in prison Source info: ?Hunt, Thomas, "Masseria’s 1913 burglary conviction," The American Mafia, mafiahistory.us, Images newspaper article on Masseria conviction Masseria Sing Sing intake form.