How Israel and Trump Can Win the War and Shape Middle East Policy
JINSA The Jerusalem Post by IDF Major General (retired) Yaakov Amidror 15 November 2024

Middle East solved!

Extracts:
  • Iran and it's proxies
If Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar had assumed that the Iranians, Hezbollah and the Palestinian Brotherhood in the West Bank would join the war with full force, he made a massive mistake – in many ways, a critical error

Hamas
However Sinwar, later killed by the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) didn’t wait to implement the Iranian plan and started the war without coordination with other “Ring of Fire” components

Perhaps all these factors played a mixed role in his decision – we can’t know for sure
  • Perhaps Sinwar felt pressured by the advancing talks between Saudi Arabia and Israel destruction
  • maybe Sinwar felt a solid religious duty and feared that continued economic progress in Gaza would interfere with his future plans
  • or Sinwar might have felt strong and well-prepared – while Israel appeared weak with its army torn apart by internal strife
  • The publication of the Israeli laser defense system timeline might have also accelerated Sinwar’s actions

While many Hamas terrorists are still alive in Gaza, Hamas in Gaza is no longer relevant as a threat to Israel However....
Hamas still fights with its remaining forces against the IDF inside the Strip as a guerrilla organization with small coordination capability

Still, no one asked themselves how Hamas in Gaza would react to the elimination of Sinwar, its leader
Quote
Hamas’s only success is, its ability to hold Israeli and other hostages

Days earlier, Israel successfully completed the first phase of the ground operation in Gaza, dismantling and destroying Hamas’s military capabilities -- Hamas still firing....

Hezbollah
Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah (also later killed by the IDF) as the senior figure in the “resistance” array against Israel, couldn’t sit idle but also couldn’t risk a major war without preparation and after losing the element of surprise

Therefore, Hezbollah joined the fighting minimally and at a high cost as the connection to Gaza affected its decision flexibility

Over nearly a year, it lost considerable capabilities, especially in southern Lebanon (secretly, the IDF used this time to prepare for the invasion of Lebanon, including through special forces operating in Lebanese territory)

Quote
On what we call the “Beeper Night” when those holding the activation mechanism faced a use-it-or-lose-it crisis and decided to push the button – the war in Lebanon also began in full force on Israel’s initiative

Thus, with almost perfect timing between sectors, Israel, even if by chance, became free to deal with the threat from the north right before the “Beeper Night”