Trump uncuffing Israel Israel National News Arutz Sheva by Melanie Phillips 21 March 2025
Extracts:
Israel's agonizing dilemma
But the great dread is that, if Hamas feels its back is to the wall, it will murder all the living hostages It can’t be denied that this is a very real possibility
So, to some people, doing a deal to get all the hostages back seems a no-brainer Despite the suicidal price of allowing Hamas to return to power In Israel, a majority of the public strongly favors this option
The redemption of captives is viewed as an absolute obligation of the state, rooted in Jewish principles
However, those Jewish principles also hold that while the redemption of hostages is a sacred duty, this must not be achieved if the price to be paid is the capture and killing of more innocents
This is the terrible dilemma Israel has faced from the start of this war
Quote
How does a nation balance the imperative it feels to save some of its citizens from captivity, torture and death with the imperative not to sentence even more of its citizens to the same fate and instead ensure their security?