Chicago I could agree with, but American Beauty?! 2001?! Some overrated films I've seen include Donnie Darko, the two Spider-Man films, Tim Burton's Batman films, and the original Friday the 13th. (The last of which is really just a well-intentioned rip-off, in terms of style, of the superior Halloween set in the woods). Now, that is not to say I don't enjoy or thoroughly dislike any of these films however.