Bucky - FINALLY!!!

Ace should be next......

Ace shoulda been the one going tonight. Do I think Bucky deserved to go? Absolutely not!

Did I think Bucky had a chance to win? No, not really. But Ace should have definitely been eliminated before Bucky. Ace just isn't good. His best performances are only decent, whereas I have been genuinely entertained by Bucky.

But then again, none of the performances last night were especially good (save for Elliot and Taylor). I guess it coulda been anybody.

BYE BYE BUCKY

BYE BYE BUCKY

na na na na
hay hay hay

GOOD BYE BUCKY !

I haven't seen the show for 2 weeks now. How in the heck is Pickle still on the show and Mandisa is not? Something is wrong with that picture

I was watching a show yesterday called American Idol Extra. Has anybody seen it yet? They showed Chicken Little's homecoming. He got the key to the city he lives in some city in New York. Some pizza joint there even made a Kevin pizza with glasses :rolleyes: They showed him going back to school getting back with the choir. They had a interview with Bucky since he got eliminated and other clips from the elimination show. I guess they do this show every week. I did not know that Bucky was married.

Buckey reminds me terribly of Kiefer Sutherland.

Who to win, then?

I don't know who I want to win now since Mandisa left :rolleyes:

Well, I have to say that I was quite impressed with tonight's performances. When I first heard that it was Rod Stewart night, I was picturing a trainwreck of epic proportions, but I was very pleasantly surprised. I think that they all did quite well.

Chris, Paris, Elliott and Katharine did so very, very well. If it comes down to the four of them, I would have a hard time voting, although I love Elliott's absolute ease with every song he sings.

Taylor started out meh, but then kicked some butt. Kellie did the opposite. She started out very, very well, but then lost it. Ace's rendition was, as Simon said, charming. I think it would be difficult to decide who to vote off this week.

SB what do you think of Ace's new look?

It looked truly painful. You could see his lovely eyes better, but I didn't like it that much. I am SO over him.

Great performances (for the most part) tonight!

"Wonderful World" would have been SO boring from anybody else, but Chris pulled it off. I'm glad to know that he can actually sing a song.

Paris was good, but forgettable. I don't even remember what she sang.

Taylor, two words: SOUL PATROL!!! I thought he did fantastic.

Elliot was great, as always.

The Pickler was absolutely horrible. I agree, it started out nice, but I ended up having to mute the television about 45 seconds into the song.

Ace did good. Nothing special.

Katharine was incredible. I can honestly see her making it to the finals and winning.

Elliot will be eliminated tomorrow. The Pickler deserves to be eliminated tomorrow.

My vote is for Pickle going home but it probably won't happen. Somebody keeps voting for her week after week. Has she evn been in the bottom 3 yet?

I don't think she has, Mig.

My thoughts on last night...

Chris - Pleasant enough. He has a nice sound to his voice. The whole time I was thinking, "Why is he dressed like a character in my Godfather game?"

Paris - I thought she did well. She does that the jazzy style well.

Taylor - Did really well. One of my favorites.

Elliot - He should have picked a better song. He really needed to stand out this week. I don't think it was enough although he still sang really well.

Pickler - Who is voting for this chick? Terrible.

Ace - Blah.

Katharine - She sang really well. Nice song choice. My only criticism is that she needed to relate to her song more - the song was about longing and she's up there smiling away.

My Bottom 3: Ace, Pickler and Elliot with Elliot leaving (although I wish it was Pickler or Ace)

DialIdol Bottom 3: Chris, Paris and Ace with Ace leaving

I (finally) just watched last night's episode...

MY thoughts...

Chris (B+) - I thought it was great, and a nice change of pace

Paris (B) - Good, in a Jazzy-Broadway kinda way

Taylor (C+) - The "+" is the for the great ending. The rest of it was nothing special, and too easy

Elliot (C) - Nothing special at all, in any way

Pickler (C-) - Started out great but lost it halfway thru

Ace (C) - It was okay; not perfect

Katharine (C-) - I think Simon's out of his mind. It was somewhat painful in spots to listen to!

MY Bottom 3 based on this week:

Pickler, Katharine, Elliott

Who Should Go: Pickler ("I'm sorry!")

OMG!! Andrea Boccelli next week!! How cool is that??

OMG!! Ace voted off this week!! How cool is that?? :p

j/k... I actually thought he was pretty good, but whatever... ya gotta go, ya gotta go!

Why in the heck is Pickle still there? Chris in the bottom 3 WTF

Although I am no fan of Kellie Pickler, I think that she has had some good performances, where Ace has just been either bad or meh. I think that he did deserve to go before her, although I don't understand why she was not at least in the Bottom 3, not ever. My brother said that the reason she hasn't is how she looked in that dress Tuesday night.

I was glad to see that Elliott wasn't in the Bottom 3. He has the most consistenly lovely voice.

DialIdol correct again last night...

So right Mig. Pickle has blonde hair blue eyes and big butt. She sings nasal and has almost zero stage presence. Go figger. Must be the sympathy-grandpa vote.

Ace could only get away with his Back Street Boy style for so long.

Agreed about Chris. Song and style wise he and Katherine are the most polished, but hey, she was in the bottom 3 once.

Next to go.......??.....who will sing the Love Song the worst? ....Paris, hmmmm. or Pickle.

It seems Ryan and Paua are feuding now? What's next for the flakehead...being kicked out of the dawg pound?

http://people.aol.com/people/articles/0,19736,1187004,00.html

Ok, I normally don't watch this show and tonight reminded me of the reason that I don't watch it. My wife and daughter are watching Idol right now and I am sitting in the same room with them doing some paperwork.

The girl Katherine just finished singing and I thought that this girl was awesome. Then I hear the assanine judges and what they said to her about her singing. Simon tells her that by choosing that song it is like her coming out and saying that she is better than Whitney Houston? :rolleyes:

To quote the famous SB ---- PUHLEEEESE!!!!!!

What a bunch of bullshit. This girl was fantastic. And I've said it before and I'll say it again, IMO this whole show is a farce because they know from day one who THEY want to win.

That girl was awesome. These judges have got to be kidding me.

And why does Paula Abdul look as though she's on something and about to have a breakdown?


Don Cardi

You see what I mean? Paula is in dire need of some serious help! Crying over this guy who didn't even come close to that girl Katherine!!!!

FIX, FIX, FIX!!!!!


Don Cardi

Katharine - I don't give a shit what the judges thought, I think she did terrific - best of the night! (A)

Elliot - It was very good, but not very exciting (B+)

Pickler - Unchained Melody is one of my favorite songs, and she totally butchered it (D)

Paris - Was pretty good, but I barely recognized it most of the time (B+)

Taylor - Could it be prophetic? "I did my best, but my best wasn't good enough" (B-)

Chris - Very good, but didn't blow me away (B+)



My Bottom 3: Pickler, Taylor, Elliot

P.S. and of course Pickler HAS to go... NOW! Don't even wail 'til Tuesday's show....!

Santino,
come're. Whattsa matter with you? I think your brain is going soft from all that comedy your playing doing paperwork.

Elliot was way better than Kathy IMHO.

My

Kathy- Didn't cut it for me tonight.

Elliott- I agree with Simon he was superb

Pickle- YUCK!! If she's not in the bottom 3 this week then the voters need to get their hearing checked.

Paris- Not great but ok

Taylor- so-so

Chris- He's got my vote tonight

I also thought that Katharine did an excellent job, and was rahter surprised at how the judges cut her to pieces. She was trying NOT to oversing the sing, which is a good thing, as shouty is not the new good.

Elliott has the most lovely voice. I think that the reason that the audience doesn't get excited over him is because:

A. He's so damned consistent.
B. He looks like the best-dressed troll under the bridge.

Chris did a good job, Taylor did a good job. Pickler was a trainwreck, and Paris tried too hard to make the song "different" from the original.

Pickler, please get off my TV!!!

Katherine - such a pretty face. Reminds me of Linda Ronstadt. Not a great song choice. Like the judges said; too big for her. I think she tried a bit too hard to belt it out Whitney style and she fell short. I'd hate to see that effort be her demise.

Elliott - Great voice, but he doesn't have the look or the delivery.

Gherkin - Get her off the stage. She's an embarrasment.

France - I can't wait to see her cry when she gets booted. Her family will probably storm the stage. If she would sing instead of act she might survive. I'm tired of her weekly make-overs.

Taylor - He looked a little lost singing a serious love song. I love his voice and style. He might hang til the end.

Chris - This guy just keeps delivering. Great voice. It gets a little too heavy metal once in awhile, but I think he's got what it takes.

Song choice, song choice, song choice.
Hope she goes - Gherkin
Hope she doesn't go - Katherine
Could go - France

DialIdol.com predicts that Paris and Kellie will be the bottom two, and that Paris will be going home. Interesting if the women slowly get picked off, and only the men are left. I don't think they've ever had an all male Top Three? Who was third in Season 3? I didn't watch Idol then, but it was Ruben, Clay and who?? Anyone know?

Edit/Add: DialIdol claims that in teh last 18 eliminations, they've been correct 83% of the time.