I love, love, love my pointy-eared little Elliott, but I have to say that this show was a letdown. The only phenomenal, stand-out performance? Kat's Somewhere Over the Rainbow. Absolutely nailed it. She was poetic.

As much as I just love him and think he has the most consistent voice, and has the most control of his voice, Elliott will be leaving next week. And unless Katharine blows everyone away, I predict that Taylor will be the next American Idol.


President Emeritus of the Neal Pulcawer Fan Club