Quote
Originally posted by Caesar's Dealer:
The hit night conversation that Michael has with Tom backs up my belief that Michael had already figured out that Rocco was the ch*nk in his fortress. Otherwise, why did Michael say, "They're dead already...killed by somebody close to us."
I find a huge flaw in your theory here.

If Michael had figured out that Rocco was the traiter when he was having that conversation with Tom, then Michael would have taken Rocco out! Michael would not have allowed Rocco to sit in on important meetings and especially the decision to take out Roth.

We would have seen Rocco wacked had Michael suspected that early in the movie that Rocco was the traitor.

We saw him take his own brother out for God's sake. If your theory held any water, we would have surely seen him take out Rocco.

Your theory has too many flaws.

IMO Plaw's theory is much more reasonable.


Don Cardi cool


Don Cardi cool

Five - ten years from now, they're gonna wish there was American Cosa Nostra. Five - ten years from now, they're gonna miss John Gotti.