As said, I will go along with the majority. I have no problem with any of the places mentioned, but Old Man Rafferty's sounds more like a pub than a restaurant (not that there's anything wrong with that). If we want a dining experience, then I don't know if I'd put it on the short list. However, please let me stress again that I will be happy to eat wherever you all want.

I did email the hotel, and they do not supply a shuttle, but do work with companies that do, in case we're worried about having a few and then driving home.