Safe or ...?

Jason won't be B3 so guess everyone's safe?

Here's the tell:

Kristy is ...... "safe"????!!!!

B3 is Michael, Carly and Syesha??!!!!!!

Is Idol playing with us again, or mixing it up......?

Moment of Truth....

OMG another commercial...

Syesha & Carly are SAFE

Michael... Is GONE!

I'm still shocked... But Lyrics is starting... lol

Wow!! didn't see that coming.

Michael Johns!?! We need a recount. Daughtry went when there were six and we thought that was a ripoff. This is worse. I hope these voters aren't the ones registered for the November vote.
I wonder what Paula was whispering in his ear during that extended hug?

Would you like AI winner's postage stamps?

Top 7: Mariah Carey

*Love it, but starting to get a little bit old at this point: show some variety!

DC should front a popular rock band, now. He's awesome! But right for this competition? Not sure. Syesha, I think, is consistently GREAT. DA... please... great singer, but more than a talented novelty? Carly, also consistently good - but not a great week. Jason, always strong, but also always sings safely. Kristy and Brooke -- I like country -- but one needs to go this week.

I thought that Kristy Lee was a snoozefest. I don't know why Simon has lost all affection for his ringer, but he hasn't had a nice thing to say about Carly in weeks. I was grateful for her long sleeves, though.

There's something oddly hot about Jason Castro. I hate his hair, but he has great eyes and a sexy mouth and chin. I think his voice is quite pure.

I think that a final "Battle of the Davids" would be terrific. They are the most talented.

I'm beginning to see a pattern with Geoff's scoring - Syesha. Hmmmmmmm. A little crush here maybe?

Of course I missed the show last night, but I got the biased evaluation from Ms. MaryCas. She hates Kristy, can't stand Carly (screamer), loves little David, hates big David (especially his hair), likes Brooke, but knows her time is short, basically no opinion about Syesha, goo-goo for Jason (like SB). So tonight I'll catch up with the clips....after the break.

I must not be interested this season cuz I keep forgetting that it's on.

Results Show

So far...

Contestants in Group A:

Jason
Carly

Contestants in Group B:

DavidC
Kristy

...because Kristy is in it, I sure hope Group B is the Bottom 3, joined by Brooke w/ DC being safe. Or GOD FORBID the remaining 3 be the B3!

Cont'd

Contestants in Group A:

Jason
Carly
Syesha

Contestants in Group B:

DavidC
Kristy
Brooke

...and DavidA is awaiting his fate

Let me guess, the usual: "DavidA, join the group that u think is safe"

DavidA... is safe (no shit)

Syesha and DavidC swap places...

DA asked that shit question and chose to sit

B3 are Brooke, Carly and Syesha

(Syesha better be safe!)

Syesha is safe!

Safe is... Brooke

Bye, Kristy!

Bye Kristy!!

It was nice seeing Elliot. My sympathies on his mother passing.

I'll try to remember to watch it next week.

BTW Has anyone seen Hells Kitchen? It comes on Tuesday's after Idol. That head chef is one mean S O B.

I'm gay for Gordon, I admit it! No doubt about it... Love his shows!

a Man-Crush huh?

Not so much a Man-Crush* as total awe and respect for his brilliance. Kinda like Simon Cowell -- he also tells the real truth 120% of the time, whether you wanna hear it -- or it should be told -- or not.


* as opposed to, say, Al and Johnny Depp

Has anyone written here about "Star Search" which I believe was a predecessor to American Idol?

I used to watch Star Search years ago, when Ed McMahon hosted. I hadn't really noticed or seen the remake (2002-2004) much....

Well, isn't Idol really a remake of it?

American Idol is a "remake" of the UK's Pop Idol. Of course it could've been influenced by Star Search, as most things are these days on TV and in movies and on radio and in books and........ And I'm sure Star Search wasn't the first talent show on the planet, either: Remember the Gong Show?

Top 6: Andrew Lloyd Webber

Syesha's still in it: easily the best of the women. It should come down to her and the two David's. Brooke simply now has to go: restarting a song on Top 6 night?? Jason didn't click with the song, and Carly was too shouty.

I thought they were all good except for Jason. I missed Brooke having to start over. Shame on her.

One thing I didn't like was how David C. ended his song tonight.

B3 Jason,Brooke,Carly

Although I think that was a HUGE error on Brooke's part, I still think Jason deserves to go before her.

I think that Syesha and David Cook were both excellent. As for Carly, can she PLEASE put on some sleeves and get off my TV. There's something about that girl that just grates on my nerves.

I was thinking last night when Carly was singing what if Nurse wretched was singing that song? After that went through my mind I got a bad case of heart burn.

I see we're all (4 of us) coming together on opinions. My wife has that grating syndrome with Carly. The Cookster was a yawner. Brooke....ah, too bad, she seems like a sweet girl. Syesha is made for Broadway; big smile, big boobs, over-acts. Jason's heavy breathing didn't help. And the Arch-man. He's got the whole package; a little Josh Groban. My pick tonight for the showers - Jason.