Hey there! I just joined you, and must say i'm impressed. I've been a GF fan for quite a long time, and a week ago bought DVD collection, and watched all three GF's once more.

As of my fav scene/s,well... many of them, but certainly the following stand out:

GF I: Plot against Solozzo/McClusky
GF II: Mike's reaction to Kay's statement "it was an abortion". Pacino's eyes and look are gorgeous!
GF III: Mike's silent scream, following Mary's death

My favorite Michael scene is split between one in the first and one in the second. My favorite scene in Godfather I is the converstation between Michael and his father The Don in the garden. Its the only time the two have their own converstation together for an extended period of time. In the second one its where Don Corleone confronts Pantangeli. In this scene is where I was convinced Michael was most like his father, his mannerims and tone of voice. Not to mention he gives the best advice he was given by his father "Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer" -AMAZING SCENES

There are so many good Michael scenes. It would be hard to chose.

In Godfather I: When he is in the hospital and discovers his father is alone, he calls Sonny and says, "Papa's here alone. I won't panick!" and he convinces the nurse, who is very reluctant at first, to move his father to a safer location.

In Godfather II: The whole movie. Honestly, the ENTIRE movie. I love Al in Part II, it is my favorite.

In Godfather III: when he dances with his daughter Mary at the beginning might be a good choice (not many favorite scenes of Michael in Part III for me).