I can't question leaving your starting pitcher in the game when he's pitching a dominating shutout. He pulled Pelfrey as soon as he gave up a hit. Wagner came in with a 3 run lead, when the runner on base meant nothing. Bottom line is, Wagner threw a 2 strike fastball right down the middle of the plate.

...In case you missed it, Wagner actually hit Reynolds with the previous pitch, but the ump missed it.