We went to Carmine's at The Tropicana in Atlantic City last weekend for a party. The food was really outstanding!
I've now been to all three Carmine's in the tri-state area and I will say that the one up on 90th St. and the one in Atlantic City are definitely superior to the one in the theater district.
As for my favorite Italian Restaurant in Manhattan, I have to go with
IL GIGLIO on Warren Street. Outstanding food accompanied by professional service along with a nice quaint atmosphere. In my opinion one of the, if not the, best Italian Restaurants in Manhattan.