This is not in NYC (it's about an hour away), but we all went here after my aunt's funeral service this afternoon and it was great! Apparently a lot of big names have been here since '82 -- including some Rat Packers and the like -- according to all the autographed photos on the wall. I definitely wanna go back and try different things!

Jimmy’s Italian Restaurant
1405 Asbury Avenue
Asbury Park, NJ 07712