Originally posted by Anthony Lombardi:
He sounds like he should be in an opera; not a pop star.
No...he should be on Broadway. I hate she-men.
Reuben can win it, and it would be OK if he did. Josh looks about as much like an "American Idol" as I look like a tarantula. Trenyce is just a sultry whore with an ordinary voice, and Kimberly is fat with a good voice.
That little Caldwell nymphette who was cut a couple weeks back was pretty smokin', too, but she had no vocal range. I wonder how she sounds with my unit half way down her throat?
