My observations of Bee Gees night: (Ugh!)

Josh STILL looks like Shrek - (Bethie, stand still while I slap you!)

NOONE can sing Jive Talking and make it sound good.

If someone had to be booted off based on just TONIGHT'S performance? Kimberly was WAY-weak. Boring. Not her usual soulful self. And although she is very pretty, she does have a pop idol image problem.

I still wish someone (good) had sung "How Deep is Your Love"

Clay rocked with his first song. I thought it was PERFECT and he really looks better and better with every show PERFORMING, until he goes and gets chummy with Ryan and then I wonder where the stage Clay ran off to. Honestly, Clay would make a great American Idol schmooozing with the likes of Kelly and Regis, Oprah, Mary Hart, VH-1 and the like. AND - he can sing too.

In my opinion, it doesnt matter if Josh or Kimmel goes tomorrow, they are gonna have to go sometime. I dont care.

Ruben: Well, I just like that kinda booty music and he rocked on his second song. It was beautiful.

Sidebar: If any of you had the opportunity to hear Josh sing the Commodores "Three Times a Lady" on the A.I. CD I bought, you would be amazed. It is a really beautiful rendition. I still maintain they can do wonders in the studio. He sounds fabulous and romantic, believe it or not....