Originally Posted By: SEAN_SOUTH
Burke had taken over Bentvena's loanshark business while Bentvena was in prison. Henry Hill also cites this as another reason why bentvena was whacked.

DeSimone was murdered because of quite a few things that he did. I'm not sure whether the murder went down as neatly and as smoothly as it happened in the film.

I find it hard to believe Tommy would walk into such an easy trap. I heard he got snatched off the street but then I've heard alot of things.

The truth is Henry Hill probably doesn't know how it really went down and the "getting his button" aspect of the storyline is probably conjecture.

Personally I can't see Tommy walking into a trap like that. He was a stone cold psycopath killer himself and him and Burke knew every trick in the book. Of course it's entirely possible given the egos of guys like Tommy but personally I don't buy it. He knew there was reason he could be killed and it's not as if it was a hit he never would have seen coming.

I heard one story that says Tommy was snatched from the street and went down fighting, put up a hell of a fight in fact and took a lot of overpowering to make him go down.

This was a guy from North Jersey who said he used to live in Queens back in the day etc...

Anyone else hear any different than the version laid down in the movie?






Tommy wasnt the smartest guy in the world. Tommy never knew that he was in any real danger. He had killed Batts 8 years pior and nothing was done about it. I mean he was known for being a psycho but he also wanted to be a made guy badly. I mean one of the reasons why Tommy was so brutal was because his brother was an informant and Tommy felt that he had to prove himself to honor tje Desimone name. I mean i've heard a few things. Obvioudly killing billy batts/foxy was the biggest thing. Also Tommy attempted to rape karen hill who at that time was having a affair with paul vario. Joe Dogs has said that Tommy Agro came up with the being made ruse because he knew Tommy wanted to be made

Last edited by JCrusher; 10/20/12 05:34 PM.