Top 4The contestants visit Children's Hospital L.A., and have perhaps the most boring night in the history of American Idol.
Contestant's Choice
B Amber "The Power of Love"
B Angie "Who You Are"
B Candice "Find Your Love"
B- Kree "It Hurts So Bad"
AMBER was good, but not very exciting [no one was, apparently].
K: Taylor-made for your voice, amazing; N: You are so current, ready; R: Most growth, now a pro; M: Gave classic song flavor, #POW; J: Difficult to beat
CANDICE was proficient, but boring [like everyone else].
N: Wish you had stuck to the melody, don't be old fashioned; R: Love you, can't always be churchy; M: Can sing anything, risky; K: Your finding yourself; J: Second best of night
KREE was a little shaky, and a lotta Zzzzz.
R: In your blues/country element, not best vox from you; M: Had moments connected to audience; K: Gotta pour your heart out; N: Not a Top 4 performance; J: Agree with Nikki again, wrong song
ANGIE contributed to the sleepy first half.
M: Professional moment, stunning; K: Got looser along the way; M: No one compares when you're at the piano; R: 10 out of 10 out of 10, BOTN, IITWI; J: Neck-in-neck with Amber
DUET: Amber/Kree okay with "Rumor Has It"
DUET: Angie/Candice [Potential Top 2] good with "Stay"
AT&T Theme Pick: One Hit Wonders
A- Angie "Cry Me A River"
B Kree "A Whiter Shade of Pale"
B Candice "Emotion"
D+ Amber "MacArthur Park"
AMBER was just plain awful this time! Judges are nuts!
K: Dominating tonight, incredible; N: Blooming flower Angie [got her name wrong!]; R: IITWI, ready, current; M: Inner star glow, quality; J: Disagree with judges, song was corny
CANDICE had good vocals as usual.
N: Classic but grooving, Super-Hero; R: Yes, yes, yes; M: Not a one hit wonder; K: Breezy, lovely, but didn't stand out; J: Better than Amber
KREE was much better.
R: Can flat out sing, brilliant; M: Have no words; K: Middle ground song, come out; N: Not gonna keep you out of Bottom 2
ANGIE was great, BOTN.
M: Elegant, clarity, beautiful; K: Mystical, celestial, powerful; N: Snatchin' wigs off heads; R: BOTN, IITWI, hands down
--
My ranking: Angie, Kree, Candice, Amber.
Amber really screwed up that last song, so had to be on the bottom. I have Candice in the middle, but she's better than that -- better than all of them -- so got 20 of my votes. Angie got the other 30 for BOTN.
I hear rumblings that they may still use the Save, despite it technically being out of play after last week. Guess we'll see....
lol