I'll go with Seven and Kevin Spacey's performance over both of them. He was in the film for only about 15 minutes but he stole the show.
Se7en was years later Ivy. Great performance anyway.
Yeah, get with it, Ivy

.
But seriously, the kid is right. We're talking about films released in 1991, and eligible for the Oscars that took place on March 30, 1992:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/64th_Academy_AwardsSee the original cape fear with Robert Mitchum I like to better then DeNiro's version.
It's not even close. Mitchum's Cady was a psychological study. DeNiro's was a cartoon character (but I should point out that I think the remake was still a good popcorn movie).
Mitchum was not nuts just wanted a little pay back
Not for nothing, Foot. But you're too fucking crazy yourself to judge what's crazy in others

.