Originally Posted By: Turnbull
Originally Posted By: The Hollywood Finochio
Vito for being too pig-headed to enter into Narcotics with Sollozzo, and Sonny for directly contradicting his father in the meeting giving Sollozzo the impetus to assasinate Vito and get Sonny go into business with him (which was a ludicrous idea knowing how devoted Sonny is to his father)..but these two events set the wheels in motion for ALL that follows.


In the novel, Sonny flat-out admits that "I shot my mouth off," and thus takes responsibility for Vito's shooting. But that's where Solozzo made a big mistake:

Sol, seeing that Sonny was hot for the deal at the meeting, figured that Sonny would still go for it with Vito either dead or incapacitated. But, Sonny could never have made the deal precisely because he showed himself hot for the deal. If he had gone for the deal, Clem, Tess and probably a lot of the men under them would have thought Sonny was a traitor to his father, and that he might even have welcomed Sol's getting his father out of the way. (N.B.: The novel says Sonny was anxious "to get out from under his father's thumb," and saw the drugs business as a way to get his own action.) Sonny could never have functioned as acting Don, or permanent Don, with that cloud over his head.


Maybe, maybe not.

Sollozzo was not unaware of Sonny's situation. He was counting on Tom to both calm Sonny down and convince the others that the Sollozzo deal was "the right thing to do."

Really, the deal made a lot of sense. I think it's plausible that the Corleone Family would have gone along with it eventually. Maybe Sonny would have been deposed or there would have been some turmoil for a while, but that really didn't matter to Sollozzo.


"A man in my position cannot afford to be made to look ridiculous!"