Maybe not exactly what you're referring to BUT:
Gets, I'll go way back to the "Stone" age. Really. That's the Rolling Stones.

I went to a party and brought the "High Tide and Green Grass" LP, which basically was a greatest hits LP. During that time it wasn't unusual to bring albums to parties. I loved that album. Anyway I forgot to take it back home with me and when I talked to the friend who had the party, she checked with everyone and of course NOBODY owned up. How do you lose an album?
TIS