Growing up my favorite was Napoli's in New Windsor, NY but they've since gone out of business unfortunately. Currently my favorite in my area of New York is Carmella's in Montgomery, NY. However, since I don't live in New York anymore, this year I decided to go on a pizza tour this holiday season. I'm really looking forward to it! The tour has great reviews and I'm going on the bus tour which only runs on Sundays. It runs 4 1/2 hours long and they visit 4 different locations, which change weekly. We're meeting up at Lombardi's on Spring Street which advertises itself as America's first pizzeria, opening in 1905. The other 3 locations won't be revealed until the day of the tour.

Scott's Pizza Tours